Teaching Strategy #14: Moderation or, Trying to Find the Golden Mean
Charlie has been more or less on the gluten-free casein-free diet since June of 1999, when he had just turned two years old. I say “more or less” because, in the past year, we started to experiment with Charlie eating the occasional hamburger bun or a bagel when a classmate’s mother brought in a special holiday breakfast or…….a piece of pizza. His teachers did not report anything amiss and Jim and I have thought he maybe seemed to run around more and to be more hyper. It is the case, though, that Charlie (who is very fond of eating, and always has been since he was a baby) often gets excited after eating, period; sometimes he even seems excited before he has a single bite.
For now, we are sticking to the diet, except when we go out for dinner and when there is a special occasion, like school parties. There are more and more gluten-free products available than when Charlie was younger—he likes the English muffins from this company and we discovered this bakery in Berkeley and he eats a great deal of batter when we make brownies from this company. “The diet” was never a huge problem for us as rice, rice noodles, spring rolls, and other Asian-type foods have always been big favorites of Charlie’s.
As Charlie has gotten older, he has become more and more aware of the world around him and he knows (why would he not) when he’s been served heated-up frozen rice crust pizza with soy cheese and there’s a nice greasy pie from a Jersey pizzeria on the other table. Lately it seems that, the more something is “off limits,” the more Charlie wants it: Last year, he liked ketchup so much he consumed half a bottle if I was not careful. I sent in a bottle to school a few months ago; there is a full bottle in plain view in a kitchen cabinet and Charlie, though knowing where it is, has yet to ask for it. He got a burger and fries in Hoboken tonight and, after eating a poppy slowly dipped bites of food into a small cup of ketchup and was more than ready for a brisk walk by Frank Sinatra Drive and Pier C, across from a glittering view of Manhattan.
When Charlie was younger, I often heard other parents whose children were older noting that one reason they had chosen to take their child off the diet was because of social issues: Their child would be invited to a pizza party and not be able to attend, or have to bring “special foods,” and this made the situation harder. Charlie of course sees that other people have buns with their burgers; why not him? And, I have been finding, by giving him “just one” instead of “simply none,” he is calmer and does not grab for other’s food (well, there’s still the odd French fry or two) and sits at the table. Hearing “no, it’s not for you” and, indeed, “no, no, no” too many times does not fall well on anyone’s ears.
We did long ago establish that milk does not agree with Charlie and, except for that occasional slice of pizza, are still staying away from dairy products; I’m still packing his lunchbox with bags of fruit and vegetables and containers of rice and edamame (which he never seems to tire of–whereas Charlie lost his appetite for potato chips when he was 7); his teacher still likes to check with me if another mother sends in cupcakes. All in moderation.
Related Stories
POSTED IN: Family, Food and Diet, Teaching Strategies







5 opinions for Teaching Strategy #14: Moderation or, Trying to Find the Golden Mean
Marla
Jan 2, 2008 at 12:05 pm
Maizie loves edamame too! Some days she can’t get enough of it.
Regan
Jan 2, 2008 at 12:10 pm
Heh-heh.
When something tastes better because it is off limits, we call it “Forbidden Fruit syndrome”, and Eleanor has a strategy of remembering the cake or other goodie leftover from after dinner, getting up quietly very early in the morning, getting dressed and going down for a slice. (I don’t think object permanence is an issue.)
Eleanor and Charlie might have a couple of things in common–she always has liked her food, and because of my Asian heritage, has lactose intolerance, so dairy is not her favorite, but Asian food is :-).
Kristina Chew, PhD
Jan 2, 2008 at 4:47 pm
Charlie eats his edamame frozen or cooked or…..with various sauces—–yes, he definitely has “forbidden fruit” syndrome. Yesterday it was an entire lop cheung (he called it a “hot dog”) and in California, a jien duy or 2.
Justthisguy
Jan 2, 2008 at 5:08 pm
“Lately it seems that, the more something is “off limits,” the more Charlie wants it…”
Bwahahahaha!!ONe!Eleven!
OMG, Charlie is showing “normal boy” tendencies!
Oh, on a more serious note, the “Caveman Diet” (look it up) is the optimum diet for humans, it’s just very expensive, which is why some of us invented agriculture (some would argue that agriculture was invented so that we could have beer)..
M'sDad
Jan 2, 2008 at 8:33 pm
M, who is also Asian, has never been a big fan of dairy — xe stated “no more baby” and rejected a milk bottle at the age of 2 1/2 (come to think of it, one of xyr last three-word sentences before we noticed that speech had almost entirely fallen off!), so that generally was not an issue when we decided to give casein-free a try at about age 5 (have been there ever since)… except for ice cream, though it’s specifically with an “ice cream infraction” that we got the sense that the casein-free diet was helpful (after having had no casein for about six months, M got into some ice cream at school and was in a stupor for about 24 hours following).
Gluten is another matter: M is a big fan of noodles… though again, after a bit over six months of gluten-free eating, we gave M some wheat pasta to see what would happen and xyr seizures spiked the following day. Good thing that (after much searching!) we found a great substitute that cooks up with almost wheat-noodle texture…
I agree that moderation is a good thing, and I look forward to the day when we can add some wheat back into M’s diet without it affecting seizures, etc. (M also seems to be sensitive to salicylates: sleep improved dramatically when we cut back salicylate foods, especially in the evening.) In the meantime, M seems to be following the pattern described above of Asian kids who enjoy lots of different kinds of food! (Current favorites: broccoli and cauliflower.)
Have an opinion? Leave a comment: